Law Book Company Must Pay $3M for Sending Junk Faxes

Gann Law Books of Newark  has agreed pay $3 million in cash and services, to settle a class-action lawsuit. Lawyers in New Jersey are required to take periodic continuing legal education (CLE) courses. Besides selling law books, Gann also provides CLE courses.  The federal Telephone Consumer Protection Act and the New Jersey Anti-Fax Statute restrict the sending of mass fax solicitations. Gann stood accused of  sending  17,0000 improper  faxes to  promote its  CLE seminars. The faxes were sent between July 26, 2007 and July 26, 2011.

The faxes did contain “opt-out” notices. The notices stated that, “to avoid receiving notices such as this one in the future, send an e-mail to Please include your name and fax number.” However, the lawsuit claimed that  the notices didn’t include a domestic phone and fax number that recipients could use to opt-out, as required by law.

The parties eventually reached a settlement. Under its terms, class members can obtain between  $175  to $875 for each fax received, but only if  a copy of the fax can be produced. If no copy was retained, class members can only get  $125,  if they  provide an affidavit stating that they received an offending fax. Each  class member is also entitled to  receive two online CLE seminars for free.

In total , Gann will pay $1.1 million  to the fax recipients,  and $1 million  to the plaintiffs attorneys. Gann will also  provide $1.9 million worth of  free CLE courses. During settlement negotiations, Any funds not claimed from the $1.1 million settlement fund must be paid to the owners  of the fax numbers to which the improper faxes were sent. Gann apparently threatened to  file for bankruptcy if it were required to pay any more.

There are several lessons here. First, if you feel that you have been the victim of an illegal commercial practice, it is very important that you keep all evidence that supports your claim. Second, if you receive improper junk faxes, you should contact an attorney to see if you qualify for compensation. Third, if you own a business, you should not conduct a mass fax campaign without  vetting it beforehand with an attorney, unless you want to get sued.

  • By Marc S. Berman
  • News